- Global Investment and Multi-Asset Strategist
United States, Institutional
Change
The views expressed are those of the author at the time of writing. Other teams may hold different views and make different investment decisions. The value of your investment may become worth more or less than at the time of original investment. While any third-party data used is considered reliable, its accuracy is not guaranteed. For professional, institutional, or accredited investors only.
With the technology-focused “Magnificent Seven” stocks accounting for about 25% of the value of the S&P 500, investors are looking for any signs that market breadth will improve and make room for other sectors and styles to outperform. I think one interesting space to explore is US small-cap stocks.
While small caps are more volatile than large-cap stocks, I see several reasons to consider an allocation to US small caps in a diversified portfolio:
- Economic growth expectations for the US are stronger than in Europe, the UK, and Japan, which could benefit domestically oriented small-cap stocks. Last year, the consensus view was that a recession was on the way. But with consumer spending remaining healthy, inflation moderating, and interest-rate cuts likely on the horizon, the economy might actually be accelerating — an environment in which small caps could excel given their greater economic sensitivity.
- Small-cap valuations look attractive relative to large caps. Small caps have underperformed large caps over the past 11 years, yet we find that historically the cycle of large-cap outperformance over small caps has averaged about 10 years and then reversed. With the small-cap forward P/E ratio at one of its lowest levels in recent years relative to the large-cap forward P/E ratio (Figure 1), a switch to small-cap outperformance may be due if the long-term pattern holds.
- The tailwinds that have given large-cap companies an edge and boosted their profits, including low taxes and light regulation, could turn to headwinds. Some large caps, including those in the tech space, have reaped the benefits of quasi-monopoly businesses. But these businesses are increasingly coming under scrutiny from policymakers and regulators.
- A large pipeline of private companies could come to the public small-cap market at relatively inexpensive valuations. The number of private companies entering the public small-cap market through an IPO slowed in the past couple of years, but that could change as economic conditions improve. In addition, small-cap stocks could be acquisition targets for large-cap companies looking for “inorganic” growth. Following a sparse year for mergers and acquisitions in 2023, activity has picked up this year, which could create unique opportunities for small-cap managers.
- The inefficiency of the small-cap market makes it potentially fertile ground for active managers. Small-cap companies are less likely than large-cap companies to be covered by research analysts — with less information available, it is more likely that the stocks may be mispriced. In addition, there tends to be more dispersion in the performance and valuations of small caps, which can make for a more attractive opportunity set for skilled stock pickers.
Figure 1
The counterarguments
There are, of course, risks to my view. Large-cap companies have advantages that could continue to serve them well in any environment, including brand, scale, data, and the power to attract and retain talent. The ability of the most successful large-cap technology companies to consistently outperform market expectations is a trend that could continue, aided by their advances in artificial intelligence. And while interest-rate cuts are widely expected later this year, the process won’t happen overnight — in the meantime, current higher interest rates could be a particular challenge for small caps, which tend to use more leverage and have more floating-rate debt.
Investment implications
- Investors may want to consider moving some large-cap exposure to small caps. After a long stretch of underperformance, small caps could be positioned for better results going forward, given their valuations and the economic outlook.
- Small caps could offer diversification in a tech-driven market. The mega-cap technology stock rally has left some portfolios with concentrated exposure to a small number of stocks. Small caps have different drivers than mega-cap tech stocks, which could help mitigate risk if the mega caps falter.
- Active managers may have an edge in small caps. The small-cap market generally has greater dispersion, greater idiosyncratic risk, and less analyst coverage than the large-cap market, creating the potential for better returns through active management.
Stay up to date with the latest market insights and our point of view.
Monthly Market Review — August 2024
A monthly update on equity, fixed income, currency, and commodity markets.
By
Brett Hinds
Jameson Dunn