- Fixed Income Credit Analyst
Skip to main content
- Funds
- Insights
- Capabilities
- About Us
- My Account
United States, Institutional
Changechevron_rightThe views expressed are those of the authors at the time of writing. Other teams may hold different views and make different investment decisions. The value of your investment may become worth more or less than at the time of original investment. While any third-party data used is considered reliable, its accuracy is not guaranteed. For professional, institutional, or accredited investors only.
The recent downturn in certain segments of the commercial real estate (CRE) sector, namely office properties, has significant ramifications for major cities because property taxes play a significant role in funding municipal operations.
Against this backdrop, we ask: Which cities could be most affected by a prolonged decline in commercial office values? Our findings indicate that large cities may be sufficiently insulated from even a severe, elongated downturn given the strength of their balance sheets and the diversity of their revenue streams.
In recent years, the health of state and local government credits has improved noticeably — it’s strong relative to historical standards. This improvement is partially the result of generous direct and indirect federal support during the pandemic and partially the result of sustained tax growth.
One potential challenge to local government credit quality is the notable decline in office values that has come about due to the shift to hybrid work schedules and tightening credit conditions, among other factors. As property taxes are a major component of local general obligation credits, we’ve decided to analyze how office valuation declines could impact major US cities.
We found that large cities should be positioned strongly enough to withstand even more severe declines effectively. Large cities may be more resilient in these scenarios because they tend to have more durable balance sheets, mainly because of their wide range of revenues. Cities usually benefit not only from property taxes, but also from sales taxes, income taxes, and intergovernmental transfers.
Like other governmental credits, city balance sheets have been buoyed by growing tax revenue (partially driven by inflation), federal aid, and manageable expenditure growth. This gives cities ample room to absorb the tax impact of office valuation declines, especially if it isn’t paired with other major revenue impacts like income tax declines or residential real estate declines (Figure 1).
To uncover the potential impact of office value declines on city balance sheets, our municipal bond investment team ran three scenarios based on different potential declines in office valuations. Our base, bear, and ultra-bear cases analyze a 15%, 30%, and 50% decline in office valuations, respectively (Figure 2).
Figure 2 highlights that the impact by major city varies, but even in the most severe ultra-bear scenario, the budget decline figures are generally less than 5%, and the years-of-cash-supply figure is almost always greater than five. We can see that among our pool of large cities, Boston is the most affected on a budget-decline basis given its dependence on property taxes and its higher tax rate for commercial real estate. Relative to cash on the balance sheet, New York is the most affected in each scenario.
We believe the years-of-cash columns in Figure 2, which show how many years the city can absorb a predicted budget decline with just the cash on its balance sheet, are noteworthy. These range from seven years (New York) to 130 years (Philadelphia) in the bear case. We believe that this exposure is manageable because under the ultra-bear scenario, even New York, with an estimated 26% decline of available cash, can absorb that impact for four years with only its existing cash cushion.
It’s worth noting that this analysis assumes there will be no other adjustments in revenues or reductions in expenditures, which would not necessarily be the case in a more extreme bear scenario. Additionally, this decline would likely happen over at least two years, which gives cities more time to react than our table accounts for.
The bottom line is that while certain segments of the commercial real estate sector may have struggled of late, large cities are prepared to weather any subsequent storms, thanks to their durable balance sheets and diverse revenue streams.
Experts
Time for bond investors to take the wheel?
Continue readingAre bond investors ready for a US industrial revolution?
Continue readingSecuritized credit: Normalizing, decelerating, or falling off a cliff?
Continue readingMultiple authors
Rate relief: Fed cuts half point, but says “economy is strong”
Continue readingDiving into the new world of credit
Continue readingCLO equity insights: Private credit
Continue readingPrivate placements: A primer for corporate DB plans preparing to derisk
Continue readingURL References
Related Insights
Stay up to date with the latest market insights and our point of view.
You've been subscribed
Thank you for subscribing. You can manage your subscription using the links provided in any of our subscription emails.
Time for bond investors to take the wheel?
Volatility makes bond investing less straightforward, but it can also create opportunities, provided investors are in a position to "take the wheel" in order to capitalise on them.
Are bond investors ready for a US industrial revolution?
Portfolio Manager Connor Fitzgerald discusses why bond investors should ready themselves for a potential US industrial revolution and shares his perspective on how to reposition portfolios for such a scenario.
Securitized credit: Normalizing, decelerating, or falling off a cliff?
Our experts offer their views on the current conditions and outlook for the securitized credit market.
Multiple authors
Rate relief: Fed cuts half point, but says “economy is strong”
Our expert explains the Fed's bold rate cut and some key takeaways for investors.
Diving into the new world of credit
Now that spreads have tightened, some investors think it's too late to invest in credit. But this assumption could be standing in the way of earning an attractive income.
CLO equity insights: Private credit
Explore how the convergence of public and private markets is impacting CLO equity, including the unexpected benefit it has driven in recent years.
Private placements: A primer for corporate DB plans preparing to derisk
With many corporate DB plans exploring derisking opportunities, Portfolio Manager Elisabeth Perenick and Multi-Asset Strategist Amy Trainor discuss the potential role that private investment-grade credit, or private placements, could play and consider common questions about liquidity and allocation sizing.
Insurance Quick Takes: US life insurers’ utilization of private placements
In our latest Insurance Quick Takes video, Tim Antonelli discusses research on US life insurers’ use of private placement investments, and shares observations for insurers globally.
Still waiting…Fed wants more data before cutting policy rates
Our expert dives into Fed policy following the July FMOC meeting.
Office to multifamily conversions: Implications for CMBS investors
Our experts explore the emerging trend in some US cities of converting office space into multi-family units and its implications for bond investors.
Multiple authors
Chart in Focus: Four key areas of opportunities in bonds amid Fed uncertainty
We discuss four key areas of opportunities in fixed income amid Fed uncertainty in the second half of the year.
URL References
Related Insights
© Copyright 2024 Wellington Management Company LLP. All rights reserved. WELLINGTON MANAGEMENT ® is a registered service mark of Wellington Group Holdings LLP. For institutional or professional investors only.