- Macro Strategist
United States, Institutional
Change
The views expressed are those of the author at the time of writing. Other teams may hold different views and make different investment decisions. The value of your investment may become worth more or less than at the time of original investment. While any third-party data used is considered reliable, its accuracy is not guaranteed. For professional, institutional, or accredited investors only.
With the first Federal Reserve rate hike expected in March, I looked at US equity market performance in the wake of previous policy lows, as shown in Figure 1. In the three months following the first tightening, we’ve typically seen the broad market weaken and defensive names dominate. Looking further out toward the 12-month mark, total returns have tended to improve.
Observations on specific sector results
I think a few details in the table are notable:
- Within cyclical sectors, energy, financials, and materials held their own in the immediate aftermath of the first tightening.
- Real estate and utilities stood out for their extremely strong performance in the last two expansions, as both were characterized by falling rates.
- Health care did well in two of the three expansions following the first tightening (the sector also screens well for being low duration and low beta).
I’d also note that defensive sectors have tended to do better in the 12 months after a Fed move than in the 12 months leading up to the move.
With all that said, this expansion is different for a lot of reasons, including the Fed’s use of both balance sheet and interest rates as policy tools, which makes extrapolation challenging.
Figure 1
A few thoughts on bond yields
There has been a lot of interest in bond yield behavior as well, which is highlighted in Figure 2. Yields typically rise ahead of the first rate hike, but then they often move down after tightening begins. This is consistent with somewhat weaker equity returns in the three months after the first Fed move. The exception was 1994, when the rate cycle was continuously revised upwards for a time.
Figure 2
Looking at market pricing of Fed rate hikes and comparing it to prior rate tightening over an expansion, there is room for the terminal rate (how high rates can go over the course of an expansion, as opposed to how much they might rise in the near future) in the US to move higher in the right global environment. Recently, in fact, market pricing for the terminal rate, which had been in the 1.75% – 2.00% range, moved north of 2.00% for the first time, and it could go higher.
The one new variable is that with Fed balance sheet runoff as an additional tool, there could be more of a tradeoff between rate hikes and balance sheet, which deserves monitoring. I continue to watch the shadow rate as a way to put the two together.
In conclusion, the move in real and nominal yields thus far in 2022 is consistent with what we have seen in prior rate tightening cycles. Looking ahead, easing supply-chain pressures should give the Fed some room in the adjustment process. Over time, I would expect some firming in real rates, especially as the starting point is quite low.
Related content
Expert
Related insights
Showing
of
Insights Posts
The power of local perspective: the long and short of European equity investing
Continue reading
7
min
Article
2025-10-31
Impact measurement and management: addressing key challenges
Continue reading
5
min
Article
2025-10-31
Decoding impact expectations: best practices for impact investors and companies
Continue reading
6
min
Article
2025-10-31
URL References
Related Insights
Stay up to date with the latest market insights and our point of view.
Read next
Showing
of
Insights Posts
Strong fundamentals, attractive valuations: Why the time may be right for active biotech investing
From solid fundamentals to supportive macro conditions, learn why our biotech experts believe the industry may be ready to run.
8
min
Article
2025-10-31
Beyond US large cap: Where now for equity investors?
How should investors navigate a narrow market? Looking ahead to the rest of the year, Macro Strategist Nicolas Wylenzek examines the structural backdrop and Equity Strategist Andrew Heiskell shares his view on equity opportunities to watch.
9
min
Article
2025-06-30
What could change the trajectory of value stocks?
Head of Multi-Asset Strategy Adam Berger and Equity Portfolio Manager Nataliya Kofman discuss “resilient” value stocks, disruptive themes, and attractive sector- and country-level opportunities.
7
min
Article
2025-05-31
Small-cap stocks: Watching for mean reversion, technology diffusion, and the next inflection point
Our experts discuss factors that could help small-cap stocks rebound and the search for winners in this inefficient segment of the market.
8
min
Article
2024-12-31
4 equity themes: Budding opportunities in small caps and more
Our expert highlights 4 areas where he sees opportunity in global equity markets.
3
min
Article
2025-04-30
A turning point for US small caps
Myth busting US small caps: why now could be a compelling entry point for the asset class.
18
min
Article
2025-04-30
Will a “Goldilocks” economy be just right for equity markets?
We provide an outlook on the ongoing shift to new investment regime, and the market segments that we expect will most heavily influence global equity performance in the coming year.
Article
2024-12-31
Why investing in themes for EM equities may reap rewards
Portfolio Manager Dáire Dunne outlines why he is increasingly optimistic about the potential opportunities within select EM equity themes this year.
Article
2024-02-29
Small-cap value: Strong past, bright future?
While equity markets have had a challenging recent past, history teaches us that there may be several reasons to be optimistic about small-cap value.
Article
2024-01-31
URL References
Related Insights
Equity Market Outlook
In our Equity Market Outlook, we offer a range of fundamental, factor, and sector insights.
Multiple authors