- Macro Strategist
Asia ex-Japan, Institutional
Change
The views expressed are those of the author at the time of writing. Other teams may hold different views and make different investment decisions. The value of your investment may become worth more or less than at the time of original investment. While any third-party data used is considered reliable, its accuracy is not guaranteed. For professional, institutional or accredited investors only.
US immigration, which is a top political issue in this important election year, has surged recently. In fact, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) recently raised its net immigration projection, effectively adding seven million people to its estimate of the US population by 2026.1 The news probably went unnoticed by many, but it has meaningful economic implications.
Before I touch on those implications, let me share a few observations on the increase in immigration we’ve seen:
- Much of the increase over the last year has come in the CBO’s “other foreign nationals” category, which the agency defines as immigrants with either a nonlegal or a pending status. The CBO estimates that this category grew by 2.4 million in 2023.2
- With the growth in immigration, the number of foreign-born people in the US has reached 49.5 million. That represents 15% of the US population, the highest level since 1890 (Figure 1).
- Faster visa processing has resulted in a normalization of permanent visas issued, but most recently the pickup in total visas issued has also been driven by an acceleration in temporary work permits under the Biden administration. Of course, there are still bottlenecks in the system, including the US asylum court, which has a backlog of over a million cases.2
It is also worth noting that there’s a significant difference between the CBO’s latest immigration estimates and those of the US Census Bureau — a cumulative gap of 10 million people. In addition, while the CBO numbers peak in 2024, stronger-than-normal immigration numbers are forecast to persist through 2026.
Are the CBO estimates plausible? The answer will depend to a great extent on the outcome of this year’s election. For example, former President Trump has promised to impose significant immigration restrictions and deport undocumented workers if he’s elected.
Figure 1
Weighing the macro impact of higher immigration
I see a number of key takeaways for growth, interest rates, and the labor force:
Growth and interest rates — By the CBO’s estimates, the demand for goods and services driven by the addition of seven million people to the US population could add 0.2% to the nation’s economic growth rate.1 A higher potential growth rate would likely mean the US economy could sustain higher interest rates for longer. It would also allow the Federal Reserve to factor a higher “neutral interest rate” — the theoretical rate at which the economy can grow sustainably without driving inflation higher — into its policy decisions.
Labor supply — An improvement in US labor supply last year, driven in part by the surge in immigration, was a critical factor in slowing wage growth and reining in inflation. From a cyclical standpoint, if the CBO’s higher immigration estimates prove to be realistic, it would suggest that the US economy could sustain a faster pace of monthly employment gains without an unwelcome increase in inflation. A recent study by the Brookings Institution estimates that this run rate could be 160,000 – 200,000 for 2024 — as much as two times the total of 100,000 predicted by many experts.2
It’s worth remembering that while immigration results in immediate population gains, the labor supply grows with a lag, given the time needed for work permits to be issued. Once immigrants have entered the labor market, research from the Bureau of Labor Statistics shows that their labor force participation rates tend to be higher than those for the native-born population, thus serving as a positive growth factor. Irrespective of current differences in labor force projections across various sources, most experts agree that immigration will drive a large proportion of US labor force growth and, therefore, immigration policies will need to be reconsidered. As I’ve written previously, shifting demographics will prompt governments around the world to focus more on labor and investment policies in years to come, with each nation having to address unique challenges — whether to focus on higher- or lower-skilled workers, for example.
Longer term, a larger labor force could also help postpone the date at which Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid face insolvency.
Challenges at the state level — On the negative side, many states are experiencing higher education, health care, and infrastructure costs as a result of the increase in immigration, making it a tough lift for the impacted parts of the country.
This, of course, helps explain in part why immigration is a top political issue in this election year. And the election results will, in turn, be a major driver of future outcomes. Again, the immigration and economic picture I’ve painted here seem plausible if we see a win for President Biden and the Democratic party. But if former President Trump returns to power and carries out his intention to aggressively restrict immigration and deport undocumented workers, it raises the risk of an abrupt negative labor supply shock, which would be inflationary.
1“The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2024 to 2034,” Congressional Budget Office, February 2024 | 2“New immigration estimates help make sense of the pace of employment,” Brookings Institution, March 2024
Pre-election ideas for investors: Lean into what you know (not what you don’t)
Continue readingMultiple authors